Tell me about a time when you had disagreements with your colleagues
Try This Question Yourself
Practice with feedback and follow-up questions
What is this question about
Interviewers use this question to understand how you behave when smart people want different things, interpret data differently, or have different risk tolerance. They are usually less interested in whether you "won" and more interested in whether you can navigate disagreement with judgment, empathy, and follow-through. For senior candidates especially, they also want to see whether you can preserve trust while still moving work forward.
Key Insights
- Conflict does not need to be emotional to be meaningful. You will give a stronger answer if you explain the underlying mismatch in goals, incentives, constraints, or risk tolerance rather than framing it as two people simply disagreeing.
- You should show your own contribution to the disagreement, even if it was small. Honest ownership is a strong maturity signal; a story where you were entirely right and everyone else was the problem usually reads as low self-awareness.
- Do not stop at 'we talked and aligned.' Explain what you did to understand the other side, what changed in the plan or your thinking, and what the outcome was for both the work and the relationship.
What interviewers probe atlevel
Top Priority
A strong junior answer shows respectful problem-solving: ask questions, suggest a path, and stay coachable.
Good examples
🟢I suggested we compare both options against the requirement and choose the one that best met the immediate need.
🟢Once I understood the concern, I proposed a smaller version of my idea that addressed the main risk they were worried about.
Bad examples
🔴I kept defending my approach in the meeting because I thought backing down would make me look weak.
🔴When they disagreed, I sent more messages explaining why I was right and waited for them to come around.
Weak answers treat disagreement as a contest; strong answers turn it into shared problem-solving.
Valuable
Example answers atlevel
Great answers
In an internship, I disagreed with another engineer about a bug fix for a checkout issue. I wanted to patch the specific error quickly, but they were concerned that my change would hide a deeper problem and create more support issues later. Instead of pushing harder in the meeting, I asked if we could walk through the recent incidents together, and I learned they had seen a similar shortcut cause repeated failures before. We ended up doing a small safe fix for the immediate problem and adding one extra check so we could confirm the root cause the next day. That delayed us by a few hours, but it prevented a repeat issue and taught me to ask for context before getting attached to my first solution. I worked with that engineer again later, and our communication was much smoother after that.
At a small startup I built a short onboarding flow and the product designer wanted a heavy animated background to make it look flashier. I was worried it would slow down the experience for users on older phones — our analytics showed about 25–30% of users were on low-end devices and support had notes about slow startup times. Rather than just push back, I made two quick prototypes (with and without the animation), measured load times, and proposed an A/B test so we could let real users decide. The designer agreed, and I also suggested lazy-loading the animation so it wouldn't block the initial view. The experiment showed no meaningful increase in conversions but did hurt load time, so we shipped the lighter version; the situation taught me to resolve design disagreements with data and concrete, low-risk experiments.
Poor answers
I had a disagreement with a teammate about how to implement part of a feature during my internship. I felt my approach was simpler, and I spent a while explaining why it made more sense. Eventually my lead agreed with me, so we moved forward with my version. It worked, and after that I usually trusted my instincts more in those discussions.
Question Timeline
See when this question was last asked and where, including any notes left by other candidates.
Late June, 2026
Mid May, 2026
Mid May, 2026
Hello Interview Premium
Your account is free and you can post anonymously if you choose.